Between Worlds: The First Generation Experience

Download MP3

Eirene: [00:00:00] I didn't have the language for it growing up, but being the oldest daughter in a first-generation household shaped the way I learned to move through the world in ways I'm still unpacking now. There is a unique kind of pressure that many first-generation children grow up carrying. Even when no one ever explains it out loud. It isn't always something dramatic or obvious. Sometimes it shows up in quiet ways. In the way you listen carefully when adults are talking about paperwork you don't fully understand yet. The way you notice your parents trying to figure out systems that are completely new to them.

You begin paying attention to things most children never think about. First-generation children often grow up with an awareness that life is bigger than their own childhood. There is the country their parents came from, the life their parents left behind, the hopes their parents carried when they arrived somewhere new, and then there is the life being built right in front of [00:01:00] them.

This is Born Tired: Where Survival Meets Healing, a podcast for those of us who grew up in survival mode but are ready to heal and speak our truth. I'm Eirene, a cycle breaker learning what peace feels like after years of survival. Every episode is an invitation to rest inside your truth, to feel seen, and to remember you were never alone. This is what it sounds like when silence finally breaks.

For many immigrant families, the journey comes both with opportunity and complexity. Opportunity because a new place can open doors that may not have existed before. Complexity because building a life somewhere new means learning how to navigate systems, languages, and expectations that may feel unfamiliar or confusing. And when parents are trying to figure those things out, children often start figuring them out too, sometimes without realizing that the roles they're stepping into are unusual for their age.

They learn how to move between cultures [00:02:00] that operate according to very different rules. You start noticing things other people don't. You learn how to adjust depending on the room you're in, and you develop a kind of adaptability that can become a strength later in life. But growing up first-generation can also create moments where belonging feels complicated, moments when you're reminded that identity is not always simple, where you can feel connected to more than one place, but never fully claimed by one.

Many people who grew up first-generation learn how to navigate that complexity quietly. They move forward, work hard, and build lives. But behind that resilience is often a childhood filled with small experiences that shaped how they understand responsibility, identity, and belonging. When people talk about the first-generation experience, they often describe it in broad terms: opportunity, sacrifice, the immigrant dream. But the reality of growing up first generation is often [00:03:00] shaped by small everyday moments.

Things that seem minor at the time, family conversations, responsibilities you take on without realizing how unusual they are for a child. When I look back at my own childhood, there are certain details that say a lot about the pressure many immigrant families carried to blend in and survive.

One of those details was something as simple as our names. None of the first generation kids in my family have a middle name, not one of us. When I asked my father about it growing up, his explanation was simple. " Americans don't have a hundred names."

In his mind, removing the middle name was practical. It was a way of sounding more American and assimilating, a way to make sure our names didn't immediately mark us as different. No one framed that as shame, but the message was clear. The less visibly other you appeared, the easier life might be.

Years later, when my own [00:04:00] children were born, my husband and I gave each of our children a middle name. It felt natural to me. I remember telling my father what we had named our firstborn. His reaction was immediate. "Why would you do that?" He asked. "Now people will know he's Hispanic." And I remember thinking, "People were going to know anyway." Their names weren't the thing revealing our identity.

Our faces carried our history. But names were only a small piece of the first generation experience, because for many of us, blending in wasn't just about how we sounded. It was also about the roles we stepped into very early. Being first generation often means growing up between two worlds.

At home, you're the child of immigrants. Outside, you're expected to function inside a system your parents are still learning themselves. And if you're the eldest daughter, that responsibility can begin very early.

You don't have an older sibling to learn from. No one's showing you how to navigate school [00:05:00] or how to ask for help or how the world outside your home works. You're learning everything in real time while also being expected to understand it quickly. Homework wasn't just about homework.

It was about figuring things out on your own and then later helping someone else with it. Learning how systems work and then becoming the one your younger siblings turn to when they don't understand something. You become the reference point. The one who goes first, who makes the mistakes, and then quietly carries the responsibility of getting it right the next time.

And a lot of that happens without anyone sitting you down and explaining it. It just becomes the role you step into. You learn how to figure things out before anyone has to ask. And in many ways, that creates strength. But it also creates a kind of parentification that can be hard to recognize when you're in it.

Because you're still a child, but parts of you are already operating like an adult. Your holding [00:06:00] responsibility, navigating things on your own, and at the same time, still needing guidance that isn't always there. You become both the one who needs support and the one who is expected to give it. And that dynamic doesn't just disappear with time.

It shapes how you show up later in life. How natural it feels to figure things out on your own. How quickly you step in for others, And how unfamiliar it can feel to be the one receiving help instead . I translated phone calls, helped fill out forms.

I navigated paperwork that even many adults find confusing. Things most children never think about became part of my responsibilities. It was framed as helping the family, and I didn't resent helping. But when a child spends years managing adult responsibilities, the nervous system learns something very specific.

You stay alert, responsible. Relaxing doesn't come naturally when your brain learned early that you had to help hold things together. [00:07:00] There is also a strange in-between space that many first-generation kids grow up in, the feeling of existing between identities.

The phrase in Spanish is, "Ni de aquí ni de allá," not from here, not from there. My family spent many summers in the Dominican Republic. But when I was there, I was the American. My Spanish had an accent. My mannerisms were different. But in the United States, I also encountered moments where my belonging was questioned, where your presence reminds others that identity in this country is still often filtered through assumptions about language, appearance, or heritage.

Living in the in-between space can create a strange tension. You learn to adapt, to read environments quickly, and to shift parts of yourself depending on the room that you're in. When I joined the Navy, people would often ask me where I was from, and I would answer honestly and say, "New Jersey."

And the [00:08:00] response was almost always the same. "No, where are you really from?" I understood what they were asking. They were asking about my ethnicity, my background, but no one was asking my white shipmates where they were really from. It was a small question that carried a much bigger message that somehow my Americanness was conditional.

I remember another moment where that awareness became very clear to me. In the community where I grew up in New Jersey, it was very diverse. A lot of Latino families, a lot of immigrant families from different places. I knew on paper that I was considered a minority, but I never really felt that in my daily life, not until I went to Navy boot camp.

For the first time, I was surrounded with more blonde-haired, blue-eyed people than I have ever seen in one place, and it wasn't a bad experience. But it was the first time I truly felt what it meant to be visibly different in a [00:09:00] room. It was the first time I understood what it meant to stand out in that way.

I also want to acknowledge something that matters to me. Being born in the United States gave me opportunities my parents didn't have. I was able to earn a college degree. I was able to build a life that might have been much harder if I had been born somewhere else. That reality can exist alongside the challenges.

Both things can be true. Like many first-generation kids, I also started working very young. I got my first part-time job when I was 15. Before that, I was paid to tutor my younger cousins, and my father required me to give him a percentage of every paycheck because it's just part of the system where you help your family. At the time, I didn't mind helping.

First-generation kids become resourceful very early. They have to. You're learning how to navigate systems your parents didn't grow up in. You're not only translating languages, but you're also translating [00:10:00] cultures and expectations. There's no blueprint for that, so you figure it out as you go.

But that kind of adaptation comes with its own emotional cost. It can create perfectionism. It can create the feeling that you have to work twice, sometimes three times harder than everyone else to prove that you belong in the room.

It can also create imposter syndrome because when you grow up in between worlds, there are moments where you feel like you don't fully belong to either one of them. Even my relationship with language reflects that. When I started kindergarten, I didn't speak any English.

I was placed in an English-speaking classroom with a teacher who didn't speak Spanish. I couldn't understand what she was saying, and she couldn't easily communicate with me either. Eventually, I learned English, but that early experience is another reminder of how first-generation kids start school already trying to catch up to systems they were just introduced to. And yet, there is also [00:11:00] something powerful about that experience.

Many first-gen kids become adaptable, observant, and resilient. They learn how to move between cultures in ways many people never have to even think about. But behind that adaptability is often a child who had to grow up faster than most. When I think about the first-gen experience now, I don't just see it as a story about culture or identity. I see it as something that shaped how responsibility showed up in my body before I had the language to question it.

Because for many of us, especially the eldest, there wasn't anyone showing us how to navigate what we were stepping into. And when you're the one who goes first, mistakes don't always feel like it's something you're allowed to have. They feel like something you need to correct quickly. Something you need to learn from immediately because there are people behind you who relied on what you figured out.

That kind of pressure doesn't always come from someone saying it out loud. It builds quietly. It [00:12:00] shows up in expectations that are never fully explained, but deeply understood. And over time, that can shape the way you relate to yourself. You get used to being capable, being dependable, being the one who can handle things. But what often goes unacknowledged is what that requires from a child. Because even though you're still growing, still learning, still needing guidance yourself, parts of you have already stepped into a role that asks for maturity, awareness, and responsibility beyond your age. The times you figured things out on your own because there wasn't anyone available to walk you through it. The times you become the steady one, even when you don't feel fully steady inside. And that pattern follows you.

It shows up in how natural it feels to take on responsibility in adulthood. How quickly you step in when something needs to be handled. How comfortable you are being the one others rely on. But it can also show up in quieter ways, [00:13:00] in how unfamiliar it feels to be supported, in how difficult it can be to ask for help without feeling like you should already have the answer.

And it shows up in how rest can feel like something that needs to be earned rather than something you're allowed to experience. And alongside all of that, there is often another layer that many first-generation adults carry. The pressure to succeed, not just for yourself, but as a continuation of everything your parents worked for, everything they left behind, everything they hoped would be possible in this new place.

That kind of pressure can be motivating. It can push you to work hard, to stay focused, to keep moving forward even when things feel uncertain. But it also creates a heavy weight you carry, a sense that your success is not just personal, that it means something beyond you, that it reflects something larger about your family, your background, your place in the world. And when [00:14:00] that pressure lives in the background for long enough, it can begin to shape how you define your worth.

You measure yourself by how much you accomplish, by how well you manage things, by how consistently you show up for others. And even when you reach milestones that once felt far away, there can still be a part of you that feels like you need to keep going, keep proving, keep moving, because slowing down doesn't always feel safe when you spent so much of your life being the one that holds things together.

But something started to shift for me when I began to look back at my experience with more awareness. I started to see the full picture. I began to understand the strength it took my parents to build a life in a new place that was unfamiliar to them.

The resilience it required to navigate systems they were learning in real time. And at the same time, I began to recognize the weight that I carried, the responsibilities that showed up early, the roles I [00:15:00] stepped into without being asked, the ways I learned to be both a child and a support system at the same time.

Both of those truths can exist together. Respect for where you come from, and compassion for what you carried. Because the reality is many first-generation children were navigating complexity before they had the space to fully understand it. And now as adults, there's an opportunity to relate to that experience differently, to recognize that the roles you stepped into were part of your environment, not the limit of who you are. To understand that being capable doesn't mean you always have to carry everything on your own. To allow space for support, for rest, or moments when you're not the one holding it all together.

And maybe that is where a different kind of strength begins, not in how much you can manage or how much you could carry, but for your ability to create space for yourself in ways that didn't exist before. To still honor your [00:16:00] story, your family, and everything that brought you here, while also allowing yourself to live in a way that feels more balanced, more supported, and more fully your own. Because the first-generation experience doesn't end in childhood. It continues to evolve, and part of that evolution is learning that you're allowed to step out of survival and into something that includes you too.

As I sit with this now, I think one of the hardest parts of the first-generation experience is learning how to hold gratitude and grief in the same place. Gratitude for the doors that opened, for the chances our parents may not have had, for the courage it took for them to begin again in a strange land. And grief for the parts of childhood that became complicated because of it. The moments where you had to understand too much too soon. The moments where you were still learning who you were while also trying to help everyone else find their way. Where being capable became something people [00:17:00] depended on before anyone stopped to ask if you were tired. That kind of grief can be hard to name because it doesn't always come with one clear event.

Sometimes it lives in the pattern, in the expectation, in the way you learned to move through the world without needing too much, asking for too much, or taking up too much space. And for many of us, healing begins when we stop minimizing that. When we say, "Yes, I had opportunities. Yes, I love where I come from. I understand the sacrifices that were made. And also, some of what I carried was heavy." That also matters because so many first-generation children grow into adults who feel like they have to choose one version of the story.

Either they honor their family sacrifice or they acknowledge their own pain. Either they feel grateful or they admit they were overwhelmed. They keep moving forward, or they pause long enough to feel what it cost them. But the truth is, [00:18:00] healing gives us room to hold more than one truth at the same time.

We can honor the people who came before us and still tell the truth about what shaped us. We can appreciate the life that was built and still recognize the child who needed more support inside it. We can be proud of our resilience while also deciding survival doesn't have to be the only way we know how to live. And maybe that is part of what makes this conversation so important.

Because when we talk about the first-generation experience honestly, we make room for the fullness of it. Not just the inspiring parts, not just the stories of hard work and success, but the emotional weight, the identity questions, the invisible responsibilities, and the quiet exhaustion that many people learn to carry without naming. And once we name it, we can begin to understand ourselves with more compassion. We begin to see that our need for rest is not laziness. Our desire for support is not [00:19:00] weakness. Our longing to belong fully without translating ourselves, explaining ourselves, or proving ourselves is not too much. It is human.

So if you grew up between worlds, I hope you let yourself honor the strength it took to survive that without turning your whole life into proof that you deserve to be here. You already do. You're allowed to belong without over-explaining your story, to succeed without carrying everyone's expectations on your back.

To love where you come from and still choose a life that gives you more peace. And maybe that is the deeper work now. Learning how to carry our story without being crushed by it. To honor our families without disappearing inside their dreams. To build something new where the next version of us gets to breathe a little easier.

If this episode resonated with you, please share it with someone who might need it, and take a moment to leave a review wherever you listen. Your review [00:20:00] helps more people find the podcast and reminds others they're not alone. Don't forget to subscribe or follow the show so you never miss an episode. You can also join me on Substack where I share weekly reflections and gentle reminders to help you feel less alone on your healing journey. You'll find the link in the show notes. If you'd like to connect beyond the podcast, you can find me on Instagram and TikTok at borntiredpodcast. I'd love to hear what resonated with you. And if you'd like to support the podcast, there's a link there to buy me a coffee.

Thank you for being here, for listening with an open heart. Most of all, remember this: your story matters, your voice matters, and you are not alone.

This episode was written and narrated by Eirene Torres. Audio production by Carlos Torres. Original music composed by Carlos Torres. [00:21:00]

Between Worlds: The First Generation Experience
Broadcast by